2026-11-17 · 6 min read · El Dorado Hills
Heritage or Four Seasons: How Do the El Dorado Hills 55+ Communities Compare?
People looking at 55+ living in El Dorado Hills usually end up comparing two names: Heritage El Dorado Hills and Four Seasons at El Dorado Hills. Both are gated. Both are age-restricted. And they feel quite different once you drive through.
At Surroundings, a real estate and lending brokerage, we help buyers compare them on the facts that matter for the next ten years, not only on the clubhouse tour.
How do the two communities differ in size and age?
Four Seasons is smaller and older. K. Hovnanian built its 460 homes from 2004 to 2009, so every sale there is a resale. Heritage is larger and newer. Lennar has built it in phases from 2015 onward, with about 1,000 to 1,060 homes at completion, depending on the source.
That age gap shows up in the homes. A Four Seasons home may be ready for updates to roofs, HVAC or kitchens over the next several years. A Heritage home is newer, and Heritage homes come with solar.
What do the homes look like?
Heritage homes are single-story, from about 1,137 to 2,993 square feet. Four Seasons has 10 floor plans of about 1,389 to 3,245 square feet.
If one level is a must, confirm the floor plan of any home you consider. Then walk it with your future needs in mind: the shower, the hallways, the garage steps.
What have homes sold for in 2026?
Maggie's MetroList pull for April through September 2026 counted 27 Heritage El Dorado Hills sales, from $460,000 to $1,150,000, with a median of $640,000. Seven were active on October 4.
The same pull counted 12 Four Seasons sales, from $559,000 to $770,000, with a median of $700,000, and one active listing on October 4. With so few homes for sale in Four Seasons at a time, buyers there may wait for the right floor plan.
How do HOA dues and Mello-Roos compare?
HOA dues are in a similar range. Heritage runs about $225 to the high $200s a month as of 2026, depending on the source. Four Seasons runs about $225 to $300 a month, billed quarterly.
Mello-Roos is where they differ. Local sources say Heritage homes carry Mello-Roos, and the amount varies by property. Local agent guides report no Mello-Roos in Four Seasons. Either way, we check the tax bill for the exact parcel before you write an offer.
What amenities does each community have?
Heritage has two clubhouses, The Resort at about 10,000 square feet and The Retreat at about 5,000, plus four lighted pickleball courts. Four Seasons has one clubhouse, The Lodge, at about 12,500 square feet, with pickleball courts and a two-acre community garden.
Neither has a golf course on site. If golf matters, ask about the resident leagues and the nearby public courses. Four Seasons has a resident golf league that plays at area courses.
What rules apply in both?
Both are 55+ communities, so California Civil Code 51.3 and each community's CC&Rs set who may live there and how long younger guests can stay. Both also have their own rules on leasing, pets and changes to the home.
Read the CC&Rs for both before you choose. They differ more than most people expect.
How far are they from health care?
Both sit within a short drive of Mercy Hospital of Folsom. It is about 3.6 miles from El Dorado Hills by the measure in our Four Seasons guide, and about 4 to 7 miles from Heritage, depending on the route.
Check the drive to your own doctors too. Many people who move from Sacramento keep their doctors for a while, and that drive is part of daily life.
Can you rent your home out later?
Possibly you can, but read the rules first. Some Heritage homes have appeared as rentals, so leasing does happen there. Both communities set lease terms and limits in their CC&Rs.
If renting the home someday is part of your plan, for example if you may move closer to family, ask for the current rental rules before your contingencies end.
The same goes for pets, solar, exterior changes and parking. Each community's rules set what you can do with the home, and they differ from Heritage to Four Seasons. Reading them early saves surprises after you move in.
How do you choose?
Tour both on the same day. Look at the homes in your price range, the clubhouses and the drive to the places you go each week. Then compare the full monthly cost, including dues, any Mello-Roos and likely repairs.
Our guides to Heritage El Dorado Hills and Four Seasons at El Dorado Hills go deeper on each. Our page on downsizing in El Dorado Hills covers selling your current home, and the 55+ Communities Guide compares the whole region.
Contact us or call or text Maggie at (916) 549-3131 or email hello@loveyoursurroundings.co to tour both communities.