2026-11-16 · 5 min read · Davis
Davis or Midtown: What Do You Give Up and What Do You Keep?
Davis and Midtown can feel like two different ways of living, and you may be drawn to both.
The question underneath: how do I pick a neighborhood when I'm new here? Davis and Midtown each give you something real. Each also asks you to give something up.
At Surroundings Real Estate & Lending, our job is not to tell you which one is better. It is to help you see what each brings so the choice is yours. Here is the comparison.
What does each place feel like on a Saturday?
In Davis, the Davis Farmers Market sets up in Central Park every Saturday morning, rain or shine. In the warmer months, it turns into Picnic in the Park on Wednesday evenings. From Old North Davis, the grid of streets just north of downtown, that is a walk of a few blocks.
In Midtown, the Midtown Farmers Market runs Saturday mornings year-round at 1050 20th Street, and the Second Saturday art walk fills the galleries and sidewalks once a month. The music venues sit close together, and Sutter's Fort is near the middle of the grid.
Which house do you get?
The typical single-family home sold in Davis ZIPs 95616 and 95618 over the past year was built in 1977, with four bedrooms and about 1,918 square feet, on a lot of about 6,970 square feet. Old North Davis is the exception: about 140 homes from before 1950, bungalows from the 1910s and 1920s and cottages from the 1930s and 1940s.
In ZIP 95816, which includes Midtown, the typical home was built in 1927, with three bedrooms and about 1,454 square feet, on a lot of about 3,920 square feet. Victorians share blocks with houses split into flats and with newer lofts and condos.
What do homes cost in each?
Over the 12 months ending September 30, 2026, half of the single-family sales in ZIPs 95616 and 95618, which cover Davis, closed between about $745,000 and $1.12 million (MetroList). In ZIP 95816, which includes Midtown, half closed between about $625,000 and $905,000. A ZIP-wide number never describes one block, and lot size, condition, square footage and more move a home within those ranges.
What do you give up in each?
In Midtown, you often give up a garage, so ask how parking works on the block. You also trade some quiet for being close to everything.
In Davis, you trade the city's density for a smaller town, and in Old North Davis you trade choice for character: the neighborhood is small and nobody is building more of it. The City of Davis made Old North one of three heritage conservation districts, so an addition, a second story or a new porch can need design review.
Midtown has its own version of that. Homes in its historic districts, such as Boulevard Park, Newton Booth or Bungalow Row, usually need city preservation review before exterior changes.
What do you keep in either one?
Quite a lot, if what you love is an older house you can walk out of. Both places put a market, a park and a train within reach of the right streets. In Davis, the Davis Food Co-op at 620 G Street and Central Park at Fourth and C streets are a few blocks from Old North Davis, whose core, the Bowers Addition, was laid out in 1913. In Midtown, the Bungalow Row district covers homes built from 1900 to 1915 along Q, 25th and 26th Streets.
The real question is less about old versus new. It is about a college town's pace or a capital city's, and which one you want outside your front door every morning.
How will you get to work?
From Midtown, light rail runs along R Street, and state offices downtown are a walk, a bike ride or a few stops away. Since the state's four-day office order took effect on July 1, 2026, that short trip counts for more.
From Old North Davis, the Amtrak station on Second Street is a short walk or ride. Practice the trip you would make most, at the hour you would make it, before you decide.
Questions about Davis and Midtown
Which one is better?
Neither. They give you different things, and the right one is the one that fits how you want to live.
Do older homes in both need extra inspections?
Often. Plan to look at the foundation, the sewer line, the electrical panel and any past additions.
Can one team help in both places?
Yes. We work in Davis and across Sacramento, and Maggie can talk through financing with you. Maggie B. Hopkins, NMLS #349517 · Surroundings NMLS #2528307. All loans subject to approval.
See both before you choose
For the full picture, see our Moving to Sacramento: The Complete Relocation Guide.
Read the Old North Davis guide, the Midtown guide and buying a home in Davis. Then tell us which streets you keep coming back to. I will help you spend a day in each, so you can feel the difference instead of reading about it.